Methodology - How We Verify & Score Affiliate Programs

Evidence classes

APrimary sources: the operator's own affiliate-program pages and terms we fetched ourselves, court records, regulator filings.
BSerious press, industry trade coverage, and established independent review outlets.
CCommunity reports (forums, Reddit) - paraphrased, linked, labeled as anecdote.
DOur own measurements. Empty until the test phase completes; program pages say so explicitly.

Citations

Every source on a program page is evidence-classed [A]-[D] and dated - the class badges render next to each source, and the strip above the source list counts them. Claims we could not verify are either dropped or explicitly marked unverified - the honest answer beats a plausible guess.

Scoring

Seven dimensions: commission value, payout reliability, transparency of terms, tracking & reporting, affiliate support, fairness of terms, ease of promotion. Weights differ per category (a casino program is judged harder on payout reliability than a tax tool). Sub-scores are derived by a fixed rulebook from documented facts - the same rules render below, and the code behind them is src/score.js. A program is never rewarded for what we could not verify.

Weights per category

Scoring weights per category
CategoryCommissionPayoutTransparencyTrackingAffiliateFairnessEase
Crypto exchanges20%18%14%14%10%14%10%
Derivatives & futures20%18%13%14%10%15%10%
Swap services22%17%14%13%10%14%10%
Software wallets18%16%13%13%10%14%16%
Hardware wallets18%16%13%12%10%13%18%
Crypto cards20%17%14%13%10%14%12%
Payment gateways20%17%14%14%11%14%10%
Crypto casinos24%20%12%12%9%14%9%
Sportsbooks24%20%12%12%9%14%9%
Poker rooms24%20%12%12%9%14%9%
Trading bots & tools20%16%14%13%10%13%14%
Tax & portfolio tools18%16%13%12%10%13%18%
Mining & cloud hashrate20%20%14%12%10%14%10%
Hosting & domains18%16%13%12%10%13%18%
VPN & privacy tools18%16%14%13%10%14%15%
Ad networks20%17%13%15%11%14%10%
Faucets & get-paid20%22%12%12%10%14%10%
Earn & lending20%20%14%12%10%14%10%
DeFi & launchpads22%18%13%13%10%14%10%
News & education18%16%13%13%10%13%17%
Jobs & freelance18%16%13%13%10%13%17%
Forex & CFD brokers22%18%13%13%10%14%10%
Web3 games22%18%13%13%10%14%10%
Shops & merchandise18%16%13%12%10%13%18%
AI services18%16%13%13%10%13%17%
Financial services20%18%14%13%10%14%11%

Column heads are abbreviated; full dimension names are in the rulebook below. A missing dimension is dropped and the rest re-normalized.

The rulebook

Each sub-score starts from a documented base and moves only on documented facts. Unknown terms contribute nothing.

Commission value

BaseBaseline 0: no documented rate scores nothing. "Up to 50%" marketing without a floor is worth less than a published 25-45% ladder.
2Published tier ladder with floor AND ceiling (revshare_min and revshare_max both documented)
2Published CPA range with floor AND ceiling
2Lifetime commissions documented (not just "recurring for 12 months")
1Published sub-affiliate rate
1Revshare at or above 40% top rate (casino/exchange standard)
1Crypto payout offered (commissions settled in BTC/USDT/...)
1Low payout minimum (<= $20 equivalent documented)
-1Only "up to X%" marketing with no floor documented

Payout reliability

BaseBaseline 2: an operating program with no payout complaints on file starts at 2. Complaints deduct, court evidence adds.
CapA program with documented scam status (refusing to pay affiliates, exit with balances) is capped at 2 - it cannot rank as reliable.
1.5Long track record: program operating 5+ years without a payout scandal
0.5Program operating 2-5 years
-1.5Payout complaints on the record (affiliate-reported non-payment or long delays)
-3Program closed or paused with balances lost (documented)
-0.5 per red flagRed flags on the record (-0.5 each, capped at -2)
-1 per incidentDocumented incidents (-1 each, capped at -2)
1Facts field-verified against the operator's own program page

Transparency of terms

Base0 points before rules apply
2Operator publishes a real terms page for the affiliate program (not just a signup form)
2Negative carryover policy explicitly documented
1.5No negative carryover (the good answer)
1Cookie window documented
1.5Payout minimum and frequency both documented
1.5Traffic rules documented (what is allowed/forbidden)
1Geo restrictions documented
-1.5Terms hidden behind login only ("register to see commissions")
-0.5Rates "individually negotiated" only - no public baseline

Tracking & reporting

BaseBaseline 2: a working dashboard is the industry floor. Postback/API support and granular reporting score above it.
2Postback / server-to-server tracking documented
1.5API access for stats
1.5Click/sub-ID level reporting documented
1Professional affiliate platform used (Cellxpert, Netrefer, Income Access, PartnerStack...)
1Real-time or near-real-time stats advertised
-2Tracking complaints on the record (missing conversions, untracked referrals)

Affiliate support

BaseBaseline 2: email support assumed. A named manager and fast channels score above it.
2Named/assigned affiliate manager documented
1.5Live chat / Telegram / Discord support for affiliates
1Multi-language affiliate support documented
-1.5Support complaints on the record (no replies, ignored tickets)

Fairness of terms

BaseBaseline 2: no documented traps and no documented friendliness both land here - terms dimension rewards DOCUMENTED fairness only.
2No negative carryover
-2Negative carryover carried forward (the worst standard answer)
1No minimum-activity clause, or a lenient one documented
-2Dormancy clause: inactive accounts closed with earnings forfeited
-1Dormancy fee on inactive balances
-1.5Minimum activity clause documented (must deliver N depositors per period)
1Brand bidding explicitly allowed (rare and valuable for PPC affiliates)
0Brand bidding forbidden
-2Commission clawback / retroactive rate cuts documented
-1Admin fee deducted from commissions (NGR adjustments beyond standard)

Ease of promotion

BaseBaseline 2: promoting anything takes work. Wide product recognition and good creative assets make it easier.
2Household-name product (Binance/Coinbase/Trezor tier) converts without education
1.5Full promo toolkit: banners, widgets, feeds, API
1Localized landing pages / multi-language creative
1Free trial / freemium product (easier first conversion)
-1KYC required for affiliates before any tracking access
-0.518+ gambling product (legal-review burden on every promo channel)

Unknown facts contribute nothing - no program is flattered for terms it never published.

Affiliate blindness

Scoring paths never read affiliate-link fields; a source-level test enforces it on every run. See how we make money.

Corrections

Sources rot and terms change - retroactive commission changes are normal in this industry. Every page carries its check date; every correction with evidence is applied and logged on the change feed.