3Commas vs Coinrule: which pays better in 2026?

Head-to-head on the terms that decide where you send traffic: commission structure, negative carryover, cookie window, payout terms, platform and restrictions - every number sourced in the linked reviews.

slight edge

3Commas

Trading bots & tools · unknown

2.6of 1030%-45% RevShare

3Commas' program is alive and paying - its own community team published updated terms in January 2026 (30% starting revshare, up to 45%, trading-volume bonuses and up to 5x exchange revenue). The friction is discoverability: the /affiliate URL renders the homepage, the affiliate T&C page 404s, and everything rate-related lives in community posts and support. For bot-focused audiences it remains a flagship program (high AOV subscriptions), but chase the exact current terms with the affiliate team before publishing numbers.

Coinrule

Trading bots & tools · unknown

1.8of 10up to 30% RevShare

Coinrule publishes unusually concrete economics: up to 30% with worked examples ($251 on a $719 Trader plan, $1,889 on Pro) and a +5% bonus above $2,500/month of referred revenue - though the odd 45-day payout cadence is slower than the monthly norm. The separate friend-referral (25%, up to $200) cannibalises confusion: two programs, two payouts, pick deliberately. Self-reported scale numbers ($327k paid since launch) are marketing figures, treat accordingly.

Short answer: 3Commas wins overall (2.6/10 vs 1.8/10). Facts checked 2026-11-22.

The terms

3Commas Coinrule
Overall score (0-10)2.61.8
Commission
Commission30%-45% RevShareup to 30% RevShare
Negative carryover––
Lifetime commissions––
Sub-affiliatesnot publishednot published
Attribution & payouts
Cookie window––
Payout termsmonthlyevery 45 days
Minimum payoutnot publishednot published
Platformin-housein-house
Rules
Geo restrictionsEU-sanctioned countries (no paid plans, per ToS)not published
Brand biddingnot publishednot published
Facts checked2026-11-222026-11-22

Score breakdown

3Commas leads on commission value (+3), transparency of terms (+1).

3CommasCoinrule
Commission value
3
0
+3
Payout reliability
2
2
·
Transparency of terms
4.5
3.5
+1
Tracking & reporting
2
2
·
Affiliate support
2
2
·
Fairness of terms
2
2
·
Ease of promotion
2
2
·

3Commas at a glance

  • Operator-confirmed 30-45% revshare on subscription fees (Jan 2026)
  • Volume-based monthly bonuses and up to 5x exchange-revenue boost
  • Large existing affiliate community with public feedback loops
  • /affiliate page renders the homepage - no public landing terms
  • Affiliate T&C page (indexed Nov 2025) now 404s
  • Cookie/sub-affiliate details only via third-party directories

Full 3Commas review →

Coinrule at a glance

  • Worked commission examples published (per-plan dollar amounts)
  • +5% volume bonus above $2,500/month
  • Both affiliate (30%) and referral (25%/$200) tracks documented
  • 45-day payout cadence (slower than monthly)
  • 'Up to' framing - the base rate floor is not stated
  • Self-reported earnings stats cannot be verified

Full Coinrule review →

FAQ

Which pays more, 3Commas or Coinrule?

3Commas publishes the higher top revshare (45% vs 30%). Rates are ceilings - check the tier ladder in each review before concluding.

Which has the safer carryover policy?

At least one program does not document its negative-carryover policy - treat it as a risk, not as "no carryover".

Which cookie window is longer?

At least one cookie window is undocumented - attribution terms you cannot see are terms you cannot plan around.

Which one pays in crypto?

Neither program documents crypto payouts - if a BTC/USDT payout is a hard requirement, check the crypto-payout category instead of guessing.

Which has the better sub-affiliate deal?

Neither publishes a sub-affiliate rate.

Which has the longer track record?

Neither has a founding year we could verify - look at the operator section in each review.

Scores and facts: meta-reviews with dated sources - 3Commas · Coinrule. Method: how we verify. More: all programs compared · all head-to-heads.